Skip to main content

INC Magazine: Don’t Redesign Your DTC Website. Replatform to Stop Bleeding Money on Legacy Tech

Ryan VanniCEO

Every week in the DTC world seems to come with the launch of some brand’s new website redesign. But when you think about it, it makes sense. More so than other businesses, DTC relies on ecommerce platforms feeling thoughtfully designed and inline with current trends and expectations. A site that looks dated is a great way to lose customer trust. So, DTC brands tend to obsess over redesigning instead of replatforming; keeping a site seemingly looking fresh and new, even when the infrastructure remains the same under the surface.

In many cases, this is a huge mistake. While a redesign changes what customers see and do—the visual identity, navigation, page layouts, content, and the path to checkout—a replatform deals with Shopify Plus, Magento, CommerceTools or other tech that actually runs the site, impacting where the catalog, checkout, orders, and customer data live and how the site connects to everything else in the business.

A redesign fixes a perception or conversion problem, like the brand looks dated, shoppers get lost, or product pages don’t sell. A replatform fixes an operational problem, like site changes take too long, cost too much, or simply can’t be built. Still, when facing operational challenges, so many DTC brands opt to redesign, signaling that they are addressing things without actually doing it.

It’s easy to understand why. A redesign feels tangible, flashy and familiar, while a replatform is harder to explain to customers and feels less exciting. But that doesn’t make it any less vital. Studies show that platform infrastructure issues eat up 10 to 20 percent of the budget meant for new products, diverted to fixing legacy tech problems. That’s a serious business problem that a website facelift alone can’t solve.

Brands that understand this difference often discover an underexplored opportunity. Take Kinder’s, a brand with a huge recipe audience but a site whose infrastructure wouldn’t allow shoppers to read those recipes and buy the ingredients right from the same page. By rebuilding the site from the ground up, using Shopify Plus with a new content system, their DTC revenue grew 210 perecent, organic traffic rose 150 percent, and customer time on site increased 85 percent. Similarly, Bonobos realized its fit expertise was a core on-and-offline business driver and replatformed so that customer fit profiles could sync between the website and in-store systems, with new checkout functionality that could do the same. Replatforms for outdoor furniture maker POLYWOOD and retailer Rainbow Shops drove better speed, lower costs and better marketing too.

While the benefit is clear, it’s not always easy to know the various considerations when navigating the road to replatforming. Here’s where to start:

  • Separate “how it looks” from “how it works”. Run a “simple change” test: how long does it take to launch a promo landing page or add a product bundle? If the answer involves a developer ticket and a multi-week wait, your problem starts below the surface, and a redesign won’t fix it.
  • Check your platform’s runway. Sometimes the technology running your website expires. So, look up your platform’s end-of-support date (here’s Adobe’s, for example). If it’s coming up soon, you won’t even have time for a redesign. The foundational replatform has to come first.
  • Price the next three years, not the next project. Sometimes, redesigns seem like the less expensive option. But when you add up the cost of future licensing, developer retainers, app fees, and workarounds, you might find out that fixing the efficiency of your site with a replatform is worth it. Rainbow Shops’ 80 percent fee reduction shows how much of a budget an aging platform can quietly absorb. Money freed up there can go toward a better redesign.
  • Keep it simple. If you’re doing it right, a replatform should initially be a 1:1 recreation of your site’s look and structure. Keep the design familiar and map every URL to protect any search equity. A deliberately unexciting migration is a successful one.

Both redesigns and replatforms have their purpose, and can even be done together when you plan and budget accordingly. But as the omni-channel brand-building becomes more essential to DTC success, using technology that allows brands to build a unified ecosystem, replatforming must be taken seriously. Those that fail to keep up may save time and money today, but will find themselves unable to compete or meet consumer needs tomorrow.

Want to talk DTC with our experts?

Message *